Questions Article 371A safeguards, India’s record of honouring agreements and calls for international oversight of any future settlement

The Naga National Council/Federal Government of Nagaland (NNC/FGN), under the leadership of Zhopra Vero, has reiterated that the historical and political aspiration of the Naga people remains self-determination and not statehood, asserting that the creation of Nagaland in 1963 did not fulfil the original demand of the Naga national movement.

In a statement issued on November 17 by its Rali Wali Ministry, the NNC/FGN maintained that the Naga political aspiration had remained consistent from the submission of the Naga Club memorandum to the Simon Commission in 1929 to the declaration of Naga Independence on August 14, 1947, and the Naga Voluntary Plebiscite in 1951.

It said these milestones established the political position of the Naga people under the banner of the Naga National Council (NNC), with self-determination as the central demand.

Statehood and the question of self-determination

The NNC/FGN alleged that the establishment of the Naga People’s Convention (NPC) in 1957, the subsequent Sixteen-Point Agreement and the creation of Nagaland State in 1963 resulted from political manoeuvring and collaboration with the Government of India after its failure to suppress the Naga national movement through military force.

It maintained that the statehood arrangement did not originate from the original Naga demand and could not be equated with recognition of the people’s historical and political rights.

The organisation also questioned the extent of Nagaland’s political autonomy, arguing that administrative arrangements and financial assistance should not be mistaken for political recognition. It cautioned against accepting statehood as the fulfilment of Naga aspirations, stating that administrative concessions were no substitute for self-determination.

Questions over constitutional safeguards

The NNC/FGN also called for a reassessment of the reliance placed on Article 371A of the Constitution, stating that its special provisions did not constitute an independent guarantee of the historical and political rights of the Nagas.

It cited the abrogation of Article 370 in Jammu and Kashmir as a reminder that constitutional protections remained subject to amendments and the political authority of the Indian State.

The organisation further recalled the transfer of Nagaland Affairs from the Ministry of External Affairs to the Ministry of Home Affairs in 1972, despite a resolution of the Nagaland Legislative Assembly opposing the move on June 29 that year. It said the transfer raised questions about the actual extent of the state’s autonomy and the effectiveness of its constitutional safeguards.

It also questioned the status of points 12 and 13 of the Sixteen-Point Agreement, stating that their implementation remained unclear.

Seeks international oversight of agreements

Expressing concern over what it described as India’s failure to honour agreements with the Nagas, the NNC/FGN referred to the Nine-Point Agreement, Sixteen-Point Agreement, Shillong Accord and the two existing agreements.

It alleged that none of the agreements had been honoured in their true letter and spirit, pointing to what it described as a recurring gap between commitments made and their implementation.

Against this backdrop, the organisation questioned whether the Nagas should enter into any future political agreement with the Government of India without the oversight and guarantee of an internationally recognised body or a consortium of credible international institutions.

It said such a body should be vested with the authority to monitor compliance and exert diplomatic pressure to ensure that an agreement was implemented in its entirety.

Calls for Naga unity

The NNC/FGN also criticised attempts to divide the common Naga cause along tribal and southern-eastern lines, stating that such divisions undermined the unity and sense of Nagahood established by Naga pioneers.

It cautioned against allowing individual interests, political opportunism and personal gains to take precedence over the collective political aspiration of the Naga people.

The organisation urged all Nagas to rise above tribal divisions and reaffirm the historical principles upon which the Naga national movement was founded. It also called for unity and mutual responsibility in pursuing the shared political cause.

Concluding, the NNC/FGN maintained that the Naga political question remained unfinished and that any resolution must be founded on historical rights, genuine political recognition and the freely expressed will of the Naga people.

“Statehood is not self-determination, administrative concessions are not political rights, and financial assistance is no substitute for an honourable political settlement,” it stated.

 

MT